| 1954 |
John C. Glover '55 (Swimming) |
| 1955 |
John C. Glover '55 (Swimming) |
| 1956 |
Douglas C. Brew '57 (Track & Field) |
| 1957 |
Douglas C. Brew '57 (Track & Field) |
| 1958 |
Joseph R. Palermo '58 (Football) |
| 1959 |
Richard N. Hoehn '59 (Tennis) |
| 1960 |
John J. Crouthamel '60 (Football) |
| 1961 |
Alan A. Rozycki '61 (Football) |
| 1962 |
Jerome H. Bentley III '62 (Swimming) |
| 1963 |
William H. King '63 (Football, Lacrosse) |
| 1964 |
John H. Carpenter '64 (Soccer, Hockey) |
| 1965 |
James M. Cooper '65 (Hockey, Lacrosse) |
| 1966 |
Peter D. Barber '66 (Soccer, Baseball) |
| 1967 |
Malcolm V. Beard '67 (Football, Baseball) |
| 1968 |
Eugene F. Ryzewicz, Jr. '68 (Football, Baseball) |
| 1969 |
Michael S. Brown '70 (Diving) |
| 1970 |
Robert B. Mlakar '70 (Football, Baseball) |
| 1971 |
J. Murry Bowden '71 (Football) |
| 1972 |
Wayne R. Young '72 (Football, Baseball) |
| 1973 |
James T. Brown '73 (Basketball) |
| 1974 |
Thomas F. Fleming '76 (Football, Hockey, Track) |
| 1975 |
Reginald Williams '76 (Football, Wrestling) |
| 1976 |
Kenneth E. Norman '76 (Track & Field) |
| 1977 |
Walter A. Malmquist '78 (Skiing) |
| 1978 |
James C. Vailas '78 (Football, Lacrosse) |
| 1979 |
Eugene F. Teevens '79 (Football, Hockey) |
| 1980 |
Ross J. Brownridge '80 (Hockey) |
| 1981 |
Larry O. Lawrence '80 (Basketball) |
| 1982 |
Shaun D. Teevens '82 (Football, Hockey) |
| 1983 |
James J. Sapienza, Jr. '85 (Cross Country, Track) |
| 1984 |
James J. Sapienza, Jr. '85 (Cross Country, Track) |
| 1985 |
James J. Sapienza, Jr. '85 (Cross Country, Track) |
